With just a few simple ingredients, you can easily bake this holiday classic — Grandma’s Pecan Pie recipe.
Over the years, I have decided that the classic dessert of pecan pie is one of my favorite desserts. Heck, if I’m being honest, it’s one of my favorite recipes.
True confession: I went on a college visit with my oldest son recently, not at the holidays mind you, and they had pecan pie on the school cafeteria dessert line. It was by far my favorite thing I ate that day. I don’t need a Thanksgiving dinner to enjoy southern pecan pie. It’s perfect to me any time of year.
And while the taste of a perfect pecan pie is the main reason I love it, the ease with which it comes together is what makes Grandma’s Pecan Pie recipe so good. With just a few simple ingredients and a fairly simple recipe, you can easily have the best pecan pie imaginable.
I know pies have this culinary fear-factor for some people who view them as exceedingly difficult to make. And some are. But around here, I specialize in EASY BAKING (I would’ve named this site “The Easy Bake Oven” if I wasn’t fairly certain a trademark challenge would ensue.) Regardless, just know that there’s nothing about this pie that’s difficult, especially if you use a storebought pie crust.
Now, about storebought pie crusts — they are not all created equal.
Most skilled bakers will tell you that a homemade pie crust is really the only way to go. And while I agree IF you’re good at making pie crust, if you’re not, then purchasing an unbaked pie shell is your best bet.
In other words, a premade pie crust is better, in my opinion, than a bad homemade crust.
What are the best storebought pie crusts?
My aunt is actually the one who can answer this question best. She’s tried them all and has narrowed down the top choices. I reached out to her before publishing this post, and here’s what I took away from our text exchange, as well as my thoughts on the matter.
Refrigerated Pillsbury pie crusts in the red box are everywhere, all the time, and very easy to use. Unfortunately, the Pillsbury crusts and virtually all refrigerated roll-out crusts have — in our opinion — a chemical taste. If you regularly use them and like them, go for it. But in our opinion, there are better options, taste-wise.
My aunt was the one who clued me in a while back that the better option in terms of a premade crust is to buy a frozen pie crust.
What are the best frozen pie crusts?
Best frozen pie crust: Mrs Smith’s. This is the result of many years of testing and testing, according to my aunt.
Runners Up (acceptable frozen pie crusts): Publix, Walmart, and Marie Callendar (although it’s pretty shallow and doesn’t hold enough filling for anything close to a deep dish pie.)
Are dry pie crust mixes good?
I’ll confess I’ve yet to try one, but I’m going to. Mainly because, according to my aunt, a pie crust mix is your best bet for combining good taste with baking ease. They’re tough to find when it’s not the holiday season. So if you see a box, grab it.
Other Frequently Asked Questions about Grandma’s Pecan Pie recipe
Can I use maple syrup in place of the corn syrup?
No. The viscosity isn’t the same, and as a result, your pie filling won’t be firm enough. Plus, ounce for ounce, corn syrup is sweeter than maple syrup. Save your maple syrup to pour over my Easy Self-Rising Flour Pancakes.
Is this MY grandmother’s recipe?
Hard to say. Both of my grandmothers were excellent bakers, as is my mother. But I don’t have a copy of a classic pecan pie recipe from either of them. I don’t remember my dad’s mom making an old fashioned pecan pie, but my mom’s mom always had a couple on her dessert table at the holidays. A full dessert table during the holiday season was her family tradition. This one is fairly close to hers, especially if you use dark corn syrup, instead of light.
Is it better to use whole pecans or chopped pecans in Grandma’s Pecan Pie recipe?
You’ll notice the picture shows whole pecans (pecan halves). I think that’s prettier. But honestly, it’s harder to cut. So I guess it’s a personal preference.Print
If you’re craving a bakery-style muffin, but want it gluten free, this recipe is the best! Made with a box of cake mix, they’re hard to resist.
A crowd favorite, this Super Easy 3 Layer Strawberry Cake takes no time to make. And it’s so deliciously yummy!
Looking for an unbelievably easy muffin recipe that tastes like they were made in a bakery? This Blueberry Muffin Cake Mix recipe is one of the best and easiest muffin recipes I’ve ever made!
You won’t believe how close this Gluten Free Focaccia recipe is to regular focaccia. Made with gluten free bread flour, it’s one of the best gluten free yeast breads you’ll ever make!
With an Oreo brownie layer and an irresistible Oreo icing, these Gluten Free Cookies and Cream brownies are the perfect pairing of delicious cookie and fudgy brownie.
With the absolute perfect amount of lemon flavor, this Easy Copycat Crumbl Lemon Cookie recipe is a lemon lovers dream!